Archuleta Or Cooks?

The American Idol season finale last night was a showdown between the two Davids. Both of them performed three different songs, one of them written for the show by the winners of song writing contest. I liked Archuleta's Idol song better but Cooks' delivery was a bit more powerful to me.

So who is it gonna be tonight? As much as I think Cooks is more prepared to win, I would still vote for Archuleta. As his song said, no one can take it away from him.

Comments

[Vítor]

Although I prefer Cook and I'd like him to win, I guess Archie will be the winner. His song choices were much smarter. He sang to win.

I still think Cook is better, but I guess he could've sung something stronger than "I still haven't found what I'm looking for" in his first round and another song he had already sung, like "Billie Jean", for the 3rd round.

[anon]

If Archuleta wins then it will be interesting - I just can't imagine him on Letterman, Leno, Kimmell etc.. Don't think I've ever seen a 17 year old devoid of personality as much as him - I still think he's 12 & lied to the producers! But in all honesty, I would prefer Cook to win but either way I don't care - They both kinda suck.